Scuttlebutt Today
  Archived Newsletters »
  Features »
  Photos »

SCUTTLEBUTT 3607 - Thursday, June 7, 2012

Scuttlebutt is published each weekday with the support of its sponsors,
providing a digest of major sailing news, commentary, opinions, features
and dock talk . . . with a North American focus.


Today's sponsors: Atlantis WeatherGear and Ullman Sails.

Until the country was awarded the Games in 1981, recreational sailing
really hadn't taken root in South Korea and the Korea Yachting Association
existed in name only. The competition took place in Busan, South Korea's
second city after the capital and host Seoul, and the countries major port.
Large numbers flocked to Korea as 360 sailors in 214 teams from 60 nations
flew their flag on the water from September 20-27 1988.

With little data and questions posed on the tide in the area, there were a
few surprises that sprung up including Great Britain's gold in the Star
class that was won by Mike McIntyre and Bryn Vaile. The pair split from the
fleet looking for turning tide to win the last race. It was their second
win of the series and handed them a surprise gold medal.

Spain's Jose Luis Doreste made a seamless transition from the 470 in which
he'd won gold in 1984 to earn a second gold in the Finn ahead of US Virgin
Island Peter Holmberg and Kiwi John Cutler.

France had won one medal since 1932 - Serge Maury's Finn gold in 1972 -
until Thierry Peponnet burst onto the scene and having won the bronze in
the 470 class in Los Angeles, together with crew Luc Pilot, Peponnet got
the gold in Busan.

Brazil celebrated for not only did Torben Grael gain the bronze in the
Star, but brother Lars got the same medal in the Tornado class.

Canada's Larry Lemieux is the only sailor, and one of 11 athletes, that
have been awarded the Pierre de Coubertin Medal which is awarded to
athletes who demonstrate the spirit of sportsmanship at the Olympic Games.

And Lemiuex put his own medal aspirations to one side on September 24 1988
when 10-15 knots turned into winds in excess of 35 knots. In a comfortable
position and on his way to silver medal in the Finn the Canadian passed
Singapore's 470 entry Shaw Her Siew and Joseph Chan who had capsized. Siew
was clinging to the hull whilst Chan was 20 metres from the boat.

Without hesitation Lemieux turned his boat and dragged Chan aboard who was
too badly hurt to climb aboard. He then in turn rescued Siew, held his boat
against the wind and waited for the Korean Navy boat to arrive.

He then resumed, finished 21st in a 32 boat fleet sacrificing his own medal
hopes. Nonetheless his heroics were rewarded and at the award ceremony,
International Olympic Committee president Juan Antonio Saramanch said, "By
your sportsmanship, self-sacrifice, and courage you embody all that is
right with the Olympic ideal." -- Read on:

EDITOR'S NOTE: While not to diminish the achievement of Mike McIntyre and
Bryn Vaile in the Star, the gold medal was practically in the grip of
Americans Mark Reynolds and Hal Haenel until a control line failed in the
final race and their mast broke. The Americans settled for silver.

Weymouth and Portland, U.K. (June 6, 2012; Day 3) - The weather forecast
for the second half of Skandia Sail for Gold has been a hot topic of
conversation for a while, and today it started to happen. The wind pick-up
this morning, and by the afternoon it was a challenging twenty knots and
change for most race courses.

"Weymouth has been demanding this week," said Charlie Buckingham (USA), who
is 11th in the Laser. "In addition to the cold, windy, and rainy
conditions, competitors have to endure a long sail out to the racecourse
and a long, savage tow upwind (if you're lucky enough to have a coach) back
to shore. All of this together has made for an exhausting three days and
the forecast shows no signs of slowing down for the next two (days)."

American Anna Tunnicliffe's world #1 match race team, which recently won
the U.S. Olympic trials, has been struggling so far this week. "It's been a
little bit of this, and a little bit of that," shred middle crew Molly
Vandemoer. "In match racing you have only one boat to beat, and if you make
a mistake they are going to capitalize on it." The team split their two
qualifying races today, but it was enough to narrowly advance to the
quarterfinal round.

Thursday's weather should make for a stellar day, with forecasts for big
wind in the afternoon moving fleet starts ahead a few hours.

Event website:
Video highlights:

Canadian team:
USA team:

BACKGROUND: Skandia Sail for Gold is held on the same venue as will be the
sailing events for the 2012 Summer Olympics, which begin July 28th. This is
the sixth of seven 2011-2012 ISAF Sailing World Cup regattas, which are
open to the sailing events chosen for the 2012 Olympic and Paralympic
Sailing Competitions. --

In 2007, Atlantis introduced the waterproof/breathable Microburst sailing
jacket. That single jacket spawned what has become our best-selling
collection of super-lightweight sailing apparel, including vests, spray
tops and pants, all designed by sailors for sailors to deliver minimum
weight and maximum packability, and all in line with the Atlantis mission
of delivering the lightest-weight full-on waterproof gear there is on the
market today. For 2012, we've added a women's vest, as well as a whole
bouquet of cool new colors, so even if you already have one, you're going
to want to add to your collection.

If sailing is anything, it's diverse. Something for everything, and nearly
futile to argue what is best. Just like people, we embrace different
things. So when Scuttlebutt 3606 posted comments from Harrison Hine, who
noted his preference for "a tactical boat like the Star compared to the hot
rods like the 49er", we knew we were opening the door.

So to balance the scale, here is a reply by Zander Kirkland, who will be
representing Bermuda at the 2012 Olympic Games... in the 49er skiff:
Respectfully, I believe Mr. Harrison Hine's remarks about 49er sailing were
off the mark in Scuttlebutt 3606. His belief that 49er sailing is all about
going fast and not worrying about shifts is categorically not true.

Has he ever witnessed 49er sailing in Weymouth in a stiff SW'ester on the
Noethe Course (3 days of Olympic Racing there) or closer to home in Miami,
tucked up under Key Biscayne in a 15kt Easterly? These are both examples of
shifty venues, where it is essential to stay in phase to get ahead.

We sail short legs, often in flat water, where the speed advantage maybe 2
-3 boat lengths over a beat. Yes, you want speed to be able to hold your
lane, but if you are going the wrong way, you have no chance. 49ers can
tack quite fast in flat water and the momentary loss in speed is far
outweighed by playing the shift.

This is coming from a sailor who has only been sailing 49ers full-time for
2 years versus 17 years of racing in slow, traditional boats (Optimists,
Lasers, 420s, college sailing, FJs, Etchells and IODs), where you allude
"REAL sailing" lives. I would counter that skiff sailing is every much as
tactical as traditional sailing, but made more difficult by the high speeds
which make quick decision making essential.

The thing with skiff sailing is the boat handling is a huge barrier to
entry before you are racing with the top teams, but once you have the boat
handling handled, 49er racing mentality is just like going out for a
college race: Good start, hold your lane, get on favored tack, manage the
fleet and keep your head out of the boat for the next shift. If you can get
in the top pack, yes you may extend on the pack, but where have you not
heard about the "rich getting richer" in our sport as a race develops?

Also the thing that struck me about the transition from college sailing to
49er racing was how much you could catch up or lose on a given leg because
of the amount of leverage you were able to get with the fast 49er - it is
easy/common to have a delta with other boats of over 100 yards (or more) on
a downwind or upwind (leg of 3/4 mile). So yes, Mr Hines, amazing comebacks
happen all the time in our class!

Austin, Texas (June 6, 2012) - The culmination of the college spring season
is the ICSA / Gill Dinghy National Championship, which pits the top 18
teams that advanced from the semi-finals that were held in Annapolis, MD on
May 12-13. Competing in Club Flying Juniors, today both A and B divisions
completed six races in the first day of the three day competition.

Light winds prevailed on Lake Travis, where the Georgetown Hoyas jumped to
an early lead, paced by A division leader Chris Barnard ('13) and Hilary
Kenyon ('13), with the B division team of Evan Aras ('12) and Katherine
Canty ('12) in second. Georgetown, after finishing fourth in the 2011
Dinghy Nationals, was the top ranked school coming in the 2012


By Elaine Bunting, Yachting World
Retired couple Krzysztof and Agniezka Zadarnowski, cruising in their Tartan
37 from Bermuda to the Azores, had sailed the last miles of the
transatlantic passage, handed their sails and were motoring the last few
hundred metres into port when an escalating sequence of events led to the
destruction of their yacht.

The pair, originally from Poland, had lived in the U.S. for 27 years and
left their home in California in 2008, sailing to the Panama Canal and the
Caribbean before leaving Bermuda in May to reach Europe in the 37ft Sulima.

They arrived in Horta, in the Azores, where I was reporting last week on
the ARC Europe Rally, just as the fiercest part of a cold front was blowing
through. Gusts to 47 knots were punching through the anchorage, raising
spray and a short chop even in the lee of the main harbour wall.

As Sulima motored in after the crew had handed sails, a sheet apparently
blew off the deck. It wrapped round the propeller and stopped the engine.

What happened next, as she ended up on the lee breakwater, was watched
powerlessly by scores of other sailors in the marina and harbour, packed at
this time of the summer. These shocking photos document one of the saddest
sailing incidents I've ever witnessed:

Congratulations to Rob Finicle and his team on "Distant Thunder" who
dominated their class last weekend, scoring first overall in the Tartan 10
fleet at the 2012 Bayview One Design Regatta in Detroit! Fully powered by
Ullman Sails, the "Distant Thunder" team won four of the nine races, always
finishing in the top five of the 12-boat fleet. The Cleveland-based team
showed speed and consistency throughout the weekend in 15-28 knots of
breeze on Lake St. Clair. Ullman Sails has been dedicated to building
high-quality, performance one design sails for over 40 years.
Invest in your performance.

Lisbon, Portugal (June 6, 2012) - With two short offshore legs and three
inshore races remaining in the 2011-12 Volvo Ocean Race, starting with
Saturday's Oeiras In-Port Race in Lisbon, just 21 points split four teams
all vying for overall victory - and any slip-up in the five remaining
scoring opportunities is now likely to be costly.

Legs 8 and 9 are both significantly shorter than the other offshore stages
in the 39,000 nm round the world race. Lisbon to Lorient (France) is less
than 2,000 miles while the sprint to Galway (Ireland) is under 500 miles --
and as the leg lengths decrease, the intensity ramps up in what promises to
be the most thrilling finale to a Volvo Ocean Race in its 39-year history.

The fleet will start Leg 8 on Sunday, which will take them to the Azores
and then back to Lorient. "It will generally be upwind to get to the Azores
and then downwind after that," said Tom Addis, navigator on third-placed
PUMA. "It's a windward-leeward with not too much reaching. With these
shorter legs ...everything has to be perfect. On the longer legs you can
have a bad one and make it back up again but these shorter legs you have to
be on the right side of everything." - Race website:

Video reports:

CALENDAR OF MAJOR EVENTS (Sponsored by West Marine)
Is your event listed on the Scuttlebutt Event Calendar? This free,
self-serve tool is the easiest way to communicate to both sailors and
sailing media. These are some of the events listed on the calendar for this
* Jun 8-10 - Chicago Sperry Top-Sider NOOD Regatta - Chicago, IL, USA
* Jun 8-12 - Mills Trophy Race - Toledo, OH, USA
* Jun 9-10 - Live on the Edge Multihull Regatta - Eugene, OR, USA
* Jun 9-15 - J/80 World Championship - Dartmouth, England
* Jun 15-17 - Great Lakes International Challenge Cup - Rochester, NY, USA
View all the events at

* Newport, RI (June 6, 2012) - Entries are closed, and America's oldest
regatta, the New York Yacht Club (NYYC) 158th Annual Regatta presented by
Rolex, officially has been declared the biggest ever, with 133 boats
entered in weekend racing, scheduled for June 10 and 11, and 104 boats
signed up for an optional and separately scored 19-mile Around the
(Conanicut) Island Race on Friday, June 9. Since 1845, the tradition of the
Annual Regatta, first hosted at the New York Yacht Club's original
clubhouse in Hoboken, N.J., has been interrupted only by war. -- Full

* Sailors from over a dozen states and Canadian provinces competed in the
two 2012 Robie Pierce Regattas for sailors with disabilities at Larchmont,
NY, co-hosted by Larchmont and American Yacht Clubs, May 31-June 3. LYC's
Commodore, Carl Olsson, sailing with Susan King and AB (able bodied sailor)
Com Crocker, dominated the open event, winning six races and placing second
in the remaining two heats. Winning a tie-breaker to take the women's event
was the crew of Julia Dorsett (Boca Raton, FL) and Audrey Kobayashi
(Kingston, Ont.) with Jenny Davey (Montreal, Que.) as the able bodied (AB)
crew. -- Full report:

* UPDATE: As a follow-up to the story in Scuttlebutt 3606 about the Delta
Ditch Run race, which finishes in Stockton, it was reported on June 6th
that the California city is preparing for a possible bankruptcy filing if
officials are unable to broker a deal with the city's creditors. Stockton,
which has the second-highest foreclosure rate in the nation, would become
the nation's largest city ever to file for bankruptcy. City Council members
late Tuesday granted the city manager authority to seek Chapter 9
bankruptcy protection in three weeks if a deal isn't made. -- Full report:

The Industry News category of the Scuttlebutt Forum provides an opportunity
for companies to announce new products and services. Here are some of
recent postings:
* Schaefer Low Friction Rings
* Ockam GPS Interface 041D3
* Sunsail Delivers New Fleet of Sailboats to San Francisco Bay
View updates here:

Scuttlebutt strongly encourages feedback from the Scuttlebutt community.
Either submit comments by email or post them on the Forum. Submitted
comments chosen to be published in the newsletter may be limited to 250
words. Authors may have one published submission per subject, and should
save their bashing and personal attacks for elsewhere.


* From Mike Moore:
In response to the letter and photos submitted by Johnny Heineken in
Scuttlebutt 3606, I realize that we all have our bias in what we like in
sailing. I've always been a sit down sailor, and while I've largely
"retired", my most recent sailing was in Finns and Stars. Needless to say I
was very sorry to see the Star eliminated (again) and would hate to see the
Finn removed as well. By the same token, I understand everyone else's
commitment to seeing their favorite classes either remain, or become,
Olympic Classes.

As far as being photogenic though, I really don't see the Kites being any
more so than a Star. Even when comparing the photos Johnny submitted to the
photo of the relatively light air Laser start also shown, I still don't see
the Kiting pictures being any more compelling. Sure, the freestyle pictures
are dramatic. There is something very cool about seeing a kiteboarder
jumping a car on a barge. But really? Is that an example of what we'll be
seeing in the Olympics? I would think no more so than the pictures of
Olympic windsurfing show the action and drama of freestyle windsurfing in
big surf. -- Forum, read on:

* From Steve Gregory:
Following the race and weather reports from the Scandia Sail for Gold
regatta, I can't help but think how futile it is to entice the media at the
Olympics to extend their coverage to the sailing events. There must be a
slew of events, in which sailing is among, which are all fighting for a
slice of space. But when it is miserable on the water, compared to the cozy
confines of an arena, which event do you think the intrepid reporters will
seek out?

"By working faithfully eight hours a day you may eventually get to work
twelve hours a day." - Robert Frost, American poet

Kaenon Polarized - KO Sailing - Doyle Sailmakers
Atlantis WeatherGear - J Boats - Point Loma Outfitting
North Sails - Allen Insurance and Financial - Ullman Sails
JK3 Nautical Enterprises - Dieball Sailing

Need stuff? Look here: