Scuttlebutt Today
  
  Archived Newsletters »
  Features »
  Photos »

SCUTTLEBUTT No. 789 - April 6, 2001


Scuttlebutt is a digest of yacht racing news of major significance; commentary, opinions, features and dock talk . . . with a North American emphasis. Corrections, contributions, press releases and contrasting viewpoints are always welcome.

A DIFFERENT FOCUS
(Following are two separate stories - neither of which is about sailboat racing - but both deal with a seldom seen side of major racing programs.)

* Cam Lewis, skipper of the 110-foot catamaran Team Adventure, today announced the names of the two schoolteachers who will join his crew for a "Route of Discovery" transatlantic passage from Spain to the Bahamas. Janet Bradley, 41, from Hamble, Hampshire, England, and Susan Rieck, 50, from Grafton, Wisconsin, USA, were chosen from amongst hundreds of applicants who sought the job through Monster.com, the global online careers site. Bradley is an English and Media Studies teacher at Bridgemary Community School, in Gosport, Hampshire, while Rieck has been a school library media specialist for the Milwaukee, Wisconsin Public Schools. Both have extensive sailing experience.

Bradley and Rieck will communicate daily from the big catamaran with students on both sides of the Atlantic, using the ship's satellite communications system to transmit written information and digital photographs via the World Wide Web. Betsy Alison, a five-time Rolex Yachtswoman of the Year, is also joining the crew and will write a regular column for the team's web page.

"It is the mission of Team Adventure to motivate young people to learn and excel, to develop their awareness of the world around them," Lewis said. With this voyage we hope to bring to life for kids the determination and the achievements of Columbus so many years ago."

Skipper Lewis is not looking for any sailing records on this voyage, but he and his crew will be concentrating on Columbus' records. Using extensive documentation of Columbus' voyage, the crew and the guest teachers will emphasize similarities and startling changes that have occurred over the intervening 500 years. All of this information will be posted on the Team Adventure website. - Keith Taylor, www.nationalgeographic.com, & www.TeamAdventure.org

* The winners of the 29er and male Laser Radial classes in Great Britian's Volvo RYA Youth Championships & Trials will be invited to join the GBR Challenge training programme for a day. These sailors have been chosen, as their classes are not selected for the Volvo Youth Sailing ISAF World Championship 2001, they will however form part of the 100 strong Volvo RYA Youth Squad.

Peter Harrison "As one of the aims of our programme is to ensure that there are British America's Cup Challenges in the future, we are keen to support youth sailing in the UK. We are delighted to link with the Volvo RYA programme to offer some of their champions the chance to join GBR Challenge for a day." - Mark Bullingham, http://www.gbrchallenge.com/

CURMUDGEON'S COMMENT: Good on ya!

DUBYA, DUBYA, DUBYA
Bipartisan product selection, presidential service. www.pyacht.com

THE RACE
Really, this diversion to the Canaries is dragging out for Team Legato which after having had to face up to winds on the nose for 48 hours, then had to cope with light airs further delaying her arrival in Las Palmas and now, with barely 50 miles left to go, there's a strong north-easterly blowing across the islands.

It was a frustrated Tony Bullimore who confirmed it last night. "We are obliged to sail with whatever wind we get, and it dropped to 2 or 3 knots for a few hours, and now we have a very strong north-easterly blowing across the islands which is causing us a few worries.

In any case, in Las Palmas a team is ready to receive the boat and change the part as quickly as possible. The local Yacht Club is on hand to help. Ron Hansford is ready to pounce with the spare part... but not a sail in sight.

These whims of the weather couldn't be better for Roman Paszke and his crew (Warta Polpharma) who are still making good progress, although not quite so fast, towards the Rock. They are also beating to weather, and the Poles only covered 247 miles in the last 24 hours. However one can just imagine their satisfaction at having retaken "the lead" in this race. - Mireille Vatine

Positions on April 6 @ 030 GMT: Warta Polpharma, 1231.1 nm from finish; Team Legato, 1391.6 nm from finish. - www.therace.org

CURMUDGEON'S COMMENT: Team Legato will not be burdened with the minimum 48 hour stopover that applied while the race was still 'official.'

LETTERS TO THE CURMUDGEON leweck@earthlink.net
(Letters selected to be printed may be edited for clarity, space (250 words max) or to exclude unfounded speculation or personal attacks. This is not a bulletin board or a chat room - you only get one letter per subject, so give it your best shot and don't whine if others disagree. We don't publish anonymous letters, but will withhold your e-mail address on request.)

* From: Scott Rohrer jsrohrer@marinersinsurance.com
I was surprised to read of the recent survey conducted by U. S. Sailing. Like the New Rules (in English), it appears that this was only posted on the web. Does U. S. Sailing intend to serve all American sailors of just those awho n-line and visiting their web site? Given the size of the membership and a response of only 220+, this is not terribly scientific polling. Has our once respected National Body degenerated into a "virtual" one?

* From: Dick Lemke Dick.Lemke@co.dakota.mn.us
Perhaps US Ailing (pun intended) will be as quick to post/respond with their results of how and when the stated priorities are met. How about a quarterly report on the status and progress? I will save this list and look forward to a year from now as to the outcomes of these stated goals, when they were met and how effective they were. Perhaps then I can add the "S" back into sailing. Until then I feel more hot winds being blown at my posterior in an attempt to prove something important is being done.

* From: Ray Wulff (Proud Scuttlebutt Sailing Club Member) RWULFF@arinc.com
In the "Out of Touch Award" category, during a recent Race Committee Seminar, the suggestion was made that competitors could keep track of starting times using their GPS. All in attendance were in agreement that this was suitable to supplement the new starting sequence. Unfortunately, no one happened to realize our class (The J-22) and many other small boats prohibit their use.

I don't mean to belabor this starting sequence issue, however I'm finding more and more R/C's amending the "official" starting sequence rules than following them to the letter. What we have is a failure to communicate. I say we should draw for anchoring slots and do it La Mans style!!!!

* From: Ed Sherman Brewster210@aol.com
After reading Phillip Lyon's letter yesterday in BUTT which addressed the beaten-up issue of US Sailing membership for crew, a light appeared at the end of the tunnel. Up until now I have been opposed to the concept, but Phillp's thoughts brought into focus two interesting issues: 1) US Sailing is the best organized support we racing skippers have and, 2) they do need and deserve support in return from ALL the racing community.

With this in mind, and realizing the influence I have over my great crew, I think I can choose the right time to encourage them to join and pay the "nominal yearly fee." No arm-twisting, but with good leadership, show them it is their best interest to become a card-carrying member. It does offend me for my governing body to tell me (not ask me) that I can't race unless all our crew are members, but since they have lightened up I will be happy to use my influence to persuade my crew to join and show support. When you think about it, if all your crew become US Sailing members their commitment to the boat will be stronger--like they have a vested interest in activities.

* From: Bruce B. Nairn bbnairn@mindspring.com
(Edited to our 250-word limit) Phillip Lyon wants us to believe that not wanting to pay US Sailing the now $50 a year is a lack of commitment on the part of sailors. The rule book fiasco coupled with the raising of the annual dues, among other things, seems reason enough not to be particularly excited about forking over the dough and has nothing to do with commitment. Considering the fact that there are something like 7 million sailing in the US every year it's no wonder only 40,000 belong to US Sailing.

Wouldn't it make more sense to lower the dues and somehow broaden the appeal? By the way, it's $15 bucks for a USGA membership and the rulebook is readily available. They also haven't found it necessary to change the tee marker colors or tee time intervals in the last 100 years.

á I have always believed that the change in the anti-barging rule a million years ago launched the "no-fault" demo derby mentality so pervasive today.

á I never thought that the racing rules were all that complicated before the crusade to simplify them commenced. The fact that the "new rules" have needed continuous rewrites is pause for reflection.

á As to the starting sequence revamp? I don't recall anyone ever pointing out that this was problematic, do you?

I feel that the majority of all of this "needed change" is very much to do about absolutely nothing while more important problems in competitive sailing go unaddressed or unresolved.

* From Grant Mitchell gpm445@msn.com
In 'Butt #788 Thomas P. Hubbell thoughtfully pointed out that Ireland has more members of its national organization than we do. And then he asks, "What's wrong with us?" Well, Mr. Hubbell - maybe it's not us. It could be that the Irish national organization has their act together - that they've 'earned' that level of support.

* From: David White dwhiteme@hotmail.com
(Edited to our 250-word limit) As a practical matter, there is little (if any) incentive to become a member of US Sailing. There are emotional and intrinsic reasons to join, but no pratical reason. Anyone can participate in a regatta, get a PHRF, IMS or other rating certificate without being a member. Anyone with a computer can get whatever information he/she needs (including the racing rules, regatta results, etc) from the US Sailing website. He/she can run races, and participate on protest committees etc. As far as I can see, the only restrictions that a sailor has from not being a member is that he/she cannot participate in any of the "ladder" events. (Junior/Senior Championships).

It is time that US Sailing get a little more stringent on it's give away policies. US Sailing Presidents communication goal is wonderful, but should be restricted to "members". I have several suggestions on how to accomplish this as follows:

(1) redesign the web site to give access to major parts to "members only" such as rules, regatta results etc. Promotional material should be left open to anyone.

(2) Make membership a condition of receiving a rating certificate - this would automatically make any non one-design racer a member and eliminate the need for regatta personnel to check memberships at registration.

(3) Require all one-design classes to require US Sailing membership of their members. If they do not, then their class could not be a member of the One Design Racing Council, and their events not publicized by US Sailing.

* From: Ralph Taylor rtaylor@informationtools.com
I think it's time to ask the Association President for specifics to implement his pledge to improve US Sailing communications with members. A specific communications plan would give members the opportunity to review it to see if it met the need.

The problem with the present upwards communication is that there are too many filters. The Association isn't hearing clearly from its members and insularity breeds a decision-making vacuum. Once the new rulebook is out, we should ask for a plan to print and distribute the 2004-2007 rules. This need can clearly be anticipated.

* From Jim Durden jdurden@ucla.edu
(RE, US Sailing, Communication) - Communication is in the eye of the beholder. I don't know what the problem is. I've received plenty of communication from US Sailing. I guess it's sailing related, if you consider solicitations to sell Christmas cards with a nautical theme, sailing related. Six, mind you, six identical, 2 1/2 ounce mailings for Christmas cards, starting July 20th, then Aug 10th, again Aug 30, then Sept 25, Oct 19 and finally Oct 23. This is the most communication I've received from US Sailing in my 23 years as a member. If only Andy Rooney was a sailor. He would have a field day with this one.

Did I order any Christmas cards? I had plenty left over from last year's solicitation.

* From: John Alofsin JWrld@aol.com
Question: Are there any men's match racing events in the US that are open to all who would pay an entry fee?

SPONSORSHIP
Rolex Watch U.S.A has returned for its fifth year to sponsor US Sailing 11 adult sailing championships. Offered in conjunction with ten of the regattas is a pre-event Rolex clinic where competitors will have the opportunity to improve their racing experience through practical skill development and individual coaching.

Under the leadership of US Sailing's Championship Committee Chair Brad Dellenbaugh, the Rolex clinic program began taking on a momentum of its own and has contributed to growth in participation at the US Sailing adult regattas. At the first 2001 event - the U.S. Multihull Championship - 20 teams will be provided with a one-day clinic featuring practice races in the Inter 20, a workshop with Inter 20 national champions Nigel Pitt and Alex Shafer (Hartwell, Ga./Eustis, Fla.) and an evening rules seminar, incorporating changes in the new racing rules.

New to the 2001 calendar is the Rolex U.S. Women's Match Racing Championship, which evolved from the long-running U.S. Women's Open Championship. Others include:

á U.S. MULTIHULL CHAMPIONSHIP: (ALTER CUP) Pensacola Yacht Club, Fla. (Inter 20) April-22-26 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. SINGLEHANDED CHAMPIONSHIP: (O'DAY TROPHY) St. Francis Yacht Club, San Francisco, Calif. (Laser) August 2-5 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. TEAM RACE CHAMPIONSHIP: (HINMAN TROPHY) New York Yacht Club, Newport, R.I. (Vanguard 15) August 3-5 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. INDEPENDENCE CUP/NORTH AMERICAN CHALLENGE: (HOVEY and EAGLE TROPHIES) Chicago Yacht Club, Ill. (Martin 16) August 3-6 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. WOMEN'S SAILING CHAMPIONSHIP: (ADAMS TROPHY) Rush Creek Yacht Club, Heath, Texas (J/22) September 11-15 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. MEN'S SAILING CHAMPIONSHIP: (MALLORY TROPHY) Rush Creek Yacht Club, Heath, Texas (J/22) September 11-15 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. MATCH RACING CHAMPIONSHIP: (PRINCE OF WALES BOWL) Fort Worth Boat Club, Texas (J/22) October 2-6 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. CHAMPIONSHIP OF CHAMPIONS: (JACK BROWN TROPHY) Cabrillo Beach Yacht Club, San Pedro, Calif. (Cal 20) October 10-14 Rolex Clinic
á U.S. OFFSHORE CHAMPIONSHIP: (LLOYD PHOENIX TROPHY) U.S. Naval Academy, Annapolis, Md. (Navy 44) October 25-28
á ROLEX INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S KEELBOAT CHAMPIONSHIP: (BENGT JULIN TROPHY) Annapolis Yacht Club, Md. (J/22), Sept. 22-28 Rolex Clinic

More information: www.ussailing.org/

ONE-DESIGN?
The Tartan Ten Class Association is looking for advice on developing a process to test a new boat / builder. The objective is to determine if this new boat performs equally with the existing boat.

The T-Ten is a successful offshore one design built in the 80's. Even though the boat has been out of production for nearly 20 years, participation continues to be strong with 42 boats in the 2000 Nationals and 40 plus boats expected for the 2001 Chicago NOOD.

LS-Ten Boats Inc. has built a new boat called the LS-10. This boat was molded from an original T-Ten and uses the same sail plan, keel, rudder, standing rigging and running rigging. The boat's deck and interior is cosmetically different than the original boat - it has a deckhouse and an enclosed head.

The Tartan Ten class organization wants to conduct a performance evaluation to determine if the LS-10 should be allowed to race on an equal basis with the T-Ten. Anyone with experience or ideas for testing the two similar platforms should contact Ted Mahoney, Tartan Ten Class Association Secretary, mahonetd@earthlink.net

Websites: www.tten.com & www.t-tenboats.com

TRANSPAC 2001
You too can have fun surfing to Honolulu this July. Here is your chance to charter the fully equipped Lidgard 45 TOWER for the race to Paradise. TOWER is an IMS 45' performance yacht with an enviable race record, winner of three TransTasmans, Lahaina Raceweek '98, first home under 50' division Transpac '99. Insurance is available. TOWER is ready to go - for you. Contact Don Clothier at crglobal@hawaii.rr.com, phone 808 521-8221 or fax 808 533-1912. See TOWER on Bill Lee's web site:
http://www.fastisfun.com

CALENDAR OF MAJOR EVENTS
* August 4-11: Skandia Life Cowes Week. Buoyed by the America's Cup Jubilee Regatta, more than 1,000 boats are expected. - www.cowesweek.co.uk

MATCH RACING
United Airlines announced that they will sponsor a match racing open championship which has been lodged with ISAF to gain grade one status. It will be organised by the RYA, and to which four America's Cup syndicates have already indicated they will send teams. Peter Harrison's GBR Challenge will have a strong presence at the event which is due to be held in mid-September. Other syndicates who have expressed interest in the United Airlines Match Racing Open are Prada, One World and Oracle.

United Airlines also announced today their sponsorship of the RYA British Match Racing Championships, which will begin this weekend with the United Airlines RYA British Universities Match Racing Championship in Weymouth. The international event will be the culmination of this program.

This follows the announcement earlier this week that the Admirals Cup 2001 will not be held in Cowes this summer. United Airlines was due to sponsor the British Sydney 40 for this event, to be crewed entirely by GBR Challenge sailors. - Mark Bullingham

FACTOID
An entire British (Olympic) squad of fifty or more sailors and support staff are already hard at work in Palma, Mallorca, seeking to repeat their success in Sydney. - Peter Bentley, ISAF's Making Waves #75, http://www.sailing.org/

THE CURMUDGEON'S ANNOUNCEMENT
In an effort to address the current energy crisis, the light at the end of the tunnel will be turned off until further notice.