SCUTTLEBUTT 3505 - Friday, January 13, 2012
Scuttlebutt is published each weekday with the support of its sponsors,
providing a digest of major sailing news, commentary, opinions, features
and dock talk . . . with a North American focus.
Today's sponsors: Amazon.com, North U, and New England Boatworks.
UPROAR REGARDING SEAMANSHIP AWARD RECIPIENT
Abu Dhabi, UAE (January 12, 2012) - The Volvo Ocean Race presents a
seamanship award after each distance leg, but the selection of two Team
Sanya crew who acted to save a mast from crashing has been widely condemned
by fellow sailors.
Richard Mason and Jared Henderson were honoured by Volvo Ocean Race
organisers for their bravery in climbing the mast to make it safe after the
boat suffered rigging damage near Madagascar in the Indian Ocean.
But, according to other sailing teams, Mason and Henderson's actions were
only necessary due to a rash tactical move by skipper Mike Sanderson and
navigator Aksel Magdahl that drove the boat straight into a tropical storm.
Andrew Cape, navigator on Telefonica, walked out of the gala prize-giving
in Abu Dhabi in protest when the award was presented while others
criticised Team Sanya's tactics.
"As skippers, it is our job to minimise the risk to our guys because there
is enough risk in this race as it is," said Chris Nicholson, skipper of
"There is no way I would entertain taking a navigational direction thinking
it could win the seamanship award. No way. The safety of the crew is
paramount. We looked at it but decided we wouldn't take the boat there."
Cape himself was incensed by the decision to give the award to Team Sanya.
"If I had asked my crew to accept that decision, they would have laughed at
me. When I saw them go, I thought good luck. They do not deserve the
seamanship award," he said.
Team Sanya made the move north on the sixth day of the second leg in a bid
to escape a low pressure trough that had stifled progress for the best part
of four days.
It was one of two radical bold decisions taken on the same day after
Groupama opted to go south in search of breeze but Team Sanya's strategy
held greater risk since they knew there was a tropical storm ahead which
they may or may not miss.
"We've been seeing this option for so long and we think it's still there.
There are some risks - mainly for the first 24 hours," Magdahl said at the
The strategy paid off for a while and they gained a 300 mile lead over the
rest of the fleet but a day later, a broken shroud supporting the mast was
spotted by a crew member and emergency repairs made before the mast fell.
-- The Telegraph, read on: http://tinyurl.com/VOR-011212
Overall leaderboard after Leg 2
1. Telefonica (ESP), Iker Martinez (ESP), 6-1-1-1, 66 pts
2. CAMPER (NZL), Chris Nicholson (AUS), 3-2-2-2, 58 pts
3. Groupama (FRA), Frank Cammas (FRA), 5-3-5-4, 42 pts
4. PUMA Ocean Racing (USA), Ken Read (USA), 2-DNF-3-3, 28 pts
5. Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing (UAE), Ian Walker (GBR), 1-DNF-4-5, 19 pts
6. Team Sanya (CHN), Mike Sanderson (NZL), 4-DNF-6-6-0**, 4 pts
** Still racing. If Team Sanya finishes the first stage of Leg 2 under
racing conditions, they will collect four points for sixth place for the
first stage of Leg 2 and then automatically add one more under race rules
for the second stage and a further two points for the Abu Dhabi In-Port
Video reports: http://www.youtube.com/user/volvooceanracevideos
Course details: http://tinyurl.com/Piracy-121111
RACE SCHEDULE: The five teams are in Abu Dhabi will compete in the In-Port
Race on Friday (Jan. 13) before they start Leg 3 to Sanya, China on
Saturday (Jan. 14). As in Leg 2, Leg 3 will be similar with a Stage 1 short
sprint to meet the ship which will transport the five boats to the safe
haven port. If all goes to plan, Team Sanya will join the fleet there, and
all six boats will compete in Stage 2 to Sanya. -
VIEWING: Watch the Abu Dhabi In-Port Race on January 13th at 10am GMT (5am
EST) and Leg 3 Start on January 14th at 10am GMT (5am EST), both with live
HD Coverage starting 15 minutes before on the Volvo Ocean Race Livestream
BACKGROUND: During the nine months of the Volvo Ocean Race, which started
in Alicante, Spain and concludes in Galway, Ireland during early July 2012,
six professional teams will sail over 39,000 nautical miles of the world's
most treacherous seas via Cape Town, Abu Dhabi, Sanya, Auckland, around
Cape Horn to Itajai, Miami, Lisbon, and Lorient. Teams accumulate points
through nine distance legs and ten In-Port races. -
QUOTE / UNQUOTE
"We need a better result in the next leg. If we don't get it, that is when
we start to panic. My feeling is that we will be similar to the Juan K
boats upwind though they might have an edge and we have not done any
running. But if we are fast upwind and fast running we could win the next
three legs and everyone will be saying how fast our boat is. Let's hope so.
I keep asking when our boat will be fast." -- Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing
skipper Ian Walker, read on: http://tinyurl.com/Telegraph-011212
ONE OF WORST DISASTERS IN RACING HISTORY
Remember THE PROVING GROUND, G. Bruce Knecht's bestselling book about the
disastrous 1998 Sydney to Hobart Race? The New York Times called is
"harrowing." The Washington Post said it was "a page-turner." Esquire
magazine declared: "What a fantastic adventure story this is." A tenth
anniversary edition of the book was recently published, and it is also
available as an e-book - which just hit the Wall Street Journal's Top 10
list! This edition also includes a new Afterword that catches up with all
of THE PROVING GROUND'S remarkable characters - and it describes how Larry
Ellison's experience in the Hobart led to his decision to pursue the
America's Cup. Start reading now: http://www.Amazon.com/theprovingground
BIGGER AND FASTER ROUND THE WORLD?
How big and how fast could a design go? It's a fascinating spiral of
calculations, including money.
How long will it be before the fastest round the world record is broken
again? Could it go down to down to 40 days and be beaten by an even bigger
multihull than the 130ft Banque Populaire V? The answer to both is a
qualified yes. It's possible. But the margins are getting smaller, the
risks higher, and the huge sums needed are in shorter supply.
This round the world record time may stay for a while (set this week at 45
days 13 hours 42 minutes and 53 seconds). It is the first time in over a
decade that another potentially faster vessel has not been in build as a
record time was being broken.
Banque Populaire cost Euros 14 million to build and it took four years to
achieve the end objective. Meanwhile, running costs have been around Euros
3 million a year. So the price tag of a venture with almost exclusively
French appeal has soared to around Euros 26 million.
You have to conclude that further development is a long way off. The
cheapest way to break the record again, though, would be to use the same
boat. Given a few tweaks and a great deal of luck with the weather, as many
as two or three extra days could be gained, according to experts.
But it's a chancy game that could take several seasons. And so we're back
to that whopping Euros 3 million bill a year to run a boat capable of doing
almost nothing else.
It's not a deal many sponsors would snap up right now. -- Elaine Bunting,
Yachting World, read on: http://tinyurl.com/YW-011212
A FEW SIMPLE RULES OF THE ROAD
Coach Rod Davis, the man behind the scenes for America's Cup challenger
Emirates Team New Zealand, blogs on the rules when they're on the road ...
The racing team has done a lot of touring since coming together in 2004.
Most of the time it has been as a small group for match racing events -
Extreme 40 regattas and the like. It's a very close-knit "community" that
you'd not find in teams of 20 or so.
We have come up with some rules that we live by.
Rule number 1
No phones at dinner. As soon as a phone comes out the offender is fined.
Fines are immediate and can be paid at the bar. Sounds old school but it
really bugs me to have a get together and someone is Skyping their sister,
surfing the net, or on Facebook. It's not right!
Special permission can be granted to have a phone on the table. I think we
gave permission once in France. At the time some questioned the wisdom of
allowing any exception to the "rules are rules" policy, but Burg's wife was
in labour back in New Zealand.
Rule number 2
Change the shirt or change your beer. It never fails to amaze me how many
people just don't get it. An example from the past: How can a team member
wearing the Emirates Team New Zealand shirt, proudly displaying our
sponsors, including Estrella Damm, order a competing beer? In the bottle no
less! Imagine if a director of Estrella Damm was socialising with his/her
team and seen drinking a competitors' product. Not a good look for anyone.
Rule number 3
While we are at it, clear away the empties. As the team has matured over
the years I don't have to use this line much. Picture this: You see
yachties sitting, having a good time, perhaps a bit loud, at a table
littered with empty beer bottles. Now picture the same scene but the only
bottles in sight are those in use. A very different perception of the same
situation. Better yet, no bottles and the beer is in a glass. All Black
management discovered long ago that people tended to drink less if they
drink from a glass.
Much more...read on:
QUOTE / UNQUOTE
"To give you a peek of how much the AC game has changed: For the 2007
America's Cup in Valencia ETNZ had 32 sailors and nine designers. For the
2013 Cup we have 11 sailors and 30 designers." - Rod Davis, Emirates Team
New Zealand coach,: http://tinyurl.com/ACUP-011212
US SAILING MEMBER BENEFITS
US Sailing skippers get a $30 discount on North U Seminars. And the first
20 registrants for any North U Seminar get a free North U Long Sleeve T.
North U Seminars are coming to nearly 40 cities; or keep your slippers on
and attend a webinar. North U is offering a full slate of Seminars,
Webinars, CDs, DVDs, Clinics, Coaching & Race Weeks through the winter and
spring of 2012. You can spend a lifetime learning to be a better sailor. We
accelerate the process.
North U: 800-347-2457 http://www.northu.com
RANDOM LEG VERSUS SAUSAGE RACES
With the holiday decorations tucked away, Southern California racers
gathered in Marina del Rey last weekend for the start of the 2012 season -
the annual 22nm race along the Los Angeles coastline to Malibu and return.
The popularity of this race - often the biggest regatta of the year on the
Santa Monica Bay - has little to do with Malibu's history of Hollywood
stars and surfing legends. What it does offer is the opportunity for a crew
of average joes to enjoy an adventurous race and not be required to do a
litany of highly skilled crew maneuvers.
Scuttlebutt editor Craig Leweck reflects on growing up in Marina del Rey.
"The buoy races are now a blur, but I fondly remember racing to Malibu. It
wasn't always a thrill, often a close reach both ways, but it was
different. Subtle tactical strategy, lots of hours tweaking sail shapes,
and the time hanging out with the crew formed bonds."
With participation in random leg racing on the increase in the SM Bay, and
sausage regattas on the decline, the new Pacific Cup Deepwater Series is
being launched in 2012 by California Yacht Club to tap into this market
demand. With a three hour target time, each unique race will explore a
different section of the Santa Monica Bay for boats rated under PHRF,
Cruising Class and ORCA.
"I can see how putting a crew together for a random leg race is way easier
than a buoy race, plus they take away some of the advantage from the highly
trained teams," noted Leweck. "If you combine fewer turns with wider racing
lanes, I suspect the racing remains closer, and the less experienced teams
can stay in the hunt."
Is your area seeing this trend? Comments welcome.
* (January 12, 2012) - Despite a blustery beginning for the 47 entrants of
the 37th Annual Fort Lauderdale - Key West Race (160 nm), challenging
conditions have led to 19 boats drop outs so far. George David's R/P 90
Rambler was first to finish today in just over 24 hours (1:00:09:45), with
the bulk of the fleet still calculating whether they can finish within the
48 hour deadline from the start on Wednesday. -- Race website:
* Charlotte Harbor, FL (January 12, 2012) - Shifty winds that grew
throughout the day shuffled and tightened the leaderboard on Day Three of
the 2012 International Association for Disabled Sailing World
Championships. By the end of racing, the leaders in all three classes
changed, setting up a highly competitive homestretch on Charlotte Harbor.
Leaders are Damien Seguin (FRA) in the 2.4mR, Alexandra Rickham/ Niki
Birrell (GBR) in the SKUD, and John Robertson/ Hannah Stodel/ Steve Thomas
(GBR) in the Sonar. Eleven races are scheduled in total for each class.
Racing resumes Friday and concludes Sunday. -- Event website:
* Organizers for the Sperry Top-Sider Charleston Race Week (April 19-22) in
Charleston, SC expect nearly 300 boats to attend the 2012 edition. Open to
one-design boats between 20-80 feet LOA, and IRC, and PHRF monohull boats
which are 24-80 feet LOA. Entry fee ranges from $450.00 to $550.00 with an
early entry discount of $50.00 available by January 31, 2012. Non-US
Sailing members shall add $25.00 to entry fee. Details:
* (January 12, 2012) - The Challenger of Record for the 34th America's Cup,
Artemis Racing, had confirmed that the partnership between Team New Zealand
(ETNZ) and Luna Rossa can not proceed with all of their publicly announced
plans without violating the Protocol for the 34th America's Cup. The
America's Cup Jury issued their decision on 28 December 2011, finding that
the partnership agreement was in conflict with rules intended to insure
teams could not manipulate some of the Protocol's cost controlling limits.
-- Full report:
PHOTOS OF THE WEEK
Some of the random photos from the sport received this week at Scuttlebutt
include disabled sailing, Rolex winners, patriotic guys, school
competition, record winners, and life in the Persian Gulf. Here are this
week's photos: http://www.sailingscuttlebutt.com/photos/12/0113/
BONUS: Photographer John Payne doesn't miss too many events in South
Florida. Here are his images from two events last weekend:
SEND US YOUR PHOTOS: If you have images to share for the Photos of the
Week, send them to the Scuttlebutt editor:
NEW ENGLAND BOATWORKS: NEW PROJECTS AND EQUIPMENT
NEB's new autoclave combined with 5-axis milling machine and skilled crew
produces the finest carbon components, including those for our 72' IRC
Mini-Maxi scheduled to launch in April. For new builds, carbon components,
race preparation and modifications, service or refits, contact NEB at
401-683-4000 or http://www.NEBoatworks.com
Go PUMA MAR MOSTRO!
VIDEO OF THE WEEK
Imagine a convention of small trailerable sailboats from past and present
boat manufacturers; a convention where you can meet fellow pocket cruiser
sailors from all over the US and Canada, check out their boats, and sail
beside them on a beautiful desert lake surrounded by jagged mountains.
It's happening... the Pocket Cruiser Convention in Lake Havasu City,
Arizona on February 13 to 20, 2012. With a 172 boats now registered from 24
U.S. states and 3 Canadian provinces, this is truly a 'birds of a feather'
event. Here's a pretty funny promotional video... enjoy:
BONUS: On a frozen lake in Minnesota, some men dare to go where few have
gone before. Want to join them? Here you go:
BONUS: Think you have what it takes to be a sailmaker? Judge for yourself
from this video of the North Sails San Diego Service crew doing some major
work on a mega yacht genoa: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WH59QHK4pK8
BONUS: Week 2 on January 13, 2012 "World on Water" Global Boating Weekly
News Show reports on the finish of Leg 2 of the Global Ocean Race in
Wellington, New Zealand, in the VOR, Sanya returns to racing in Leg 2 Stage
1 Madagascar, the World Optimist Champion is named in Napier, New Zealand,
the rest of the VOR fleet have a quick 98 mile sprint race in Leg 2 Stage 2
into Abu Dhabi, UAE, Loick Peyron and his crew are crowned Jules Verne
Trophy Champions by sailing around the world faster than any other crewed
vessel and in our action segment "Fresh to Frightening" we see the official
footage of the RNLI rescuing the grounded yacht Kestral. See it on
http://www.boatson.tv at approx 1200 GMT, 0700 EST.
SEND US YOUR VIDEOS: If you have clips to share for the Video of the Week,
send them to the Scuttlebutt editor: mailto:firstname.lastname@example.org
Scuttlebutt strongly encourages feedback from the Scuttlebutt community.
Either submit comments by email or post them on the Forum. Submitted
comments chosen to be published in the newsletter may be limited to 250
words. Authors may have one published submission per subject, and should
save their bashing and personal attacks for elsewhere.
* From Reynald Neron:
In Scuttlebutt 3504 there are two different and yet similar comments
regarding sponsorship and offshore sailing.
Peter Brown tells us that sailors should do everything they can to please
the sponsors (for the Volvo Ocean race) while John Harwood-Bee serves us a
bit more "Freedom Fries" as he does not understand the value of the Trophe
Elaine Bunting said (in Scuttlebutt 3502) earlier that Mr Fossett is not
mentioned in the Trophe Jules Verne results, and we all know why. I would
like to point out that at the time, the organisation managing the Trophe
Jules Verne denied that they wanted Mr F to pay more than his competitors.
Someone's word against someone else's...
The Trophe Jules Vernes is a marketing tool. The French (and the English)
created it to renew the interest of the sponsors for the world record. The
French (and the English) have invented offshore sailing as we know it today
in the 70s and 80s.
Yet in the 90s, as it was difficult to attract sponsors to pay for ever
more costly campaigns, the various French (and English) teams decided to
work together to create an event. They gave that event a brand name, and
are actively marketing that name, hence creating an interest for the media,
and the sponsors. Some of those sailors have been working for 20 years to
get to where they are now, and to increase the popularity of sailing in
France (and England) to where it is today. -- Forum, read on:
Don't get too excited if you finish a jigsaw puzzle in 6 months and the box
says 2 to 4 years.
SPONSORS THIS WEEK
APS - Ribcraft - North Sails - Harken
Melges Performance Sailboats - IYRS - Mount Gay Rum
Ullman Sails - Amazon.com - North U. - New England Boatworks
Need stuff? Look here: http://www.sailingscuttlebutt.com/ssc/suppliers