Knots Are Great But Beware Of Limitations
Published on October 4th, 2017
Paul Dyer, technical manager at Marlow Ropes, tests the effects of knots and splices on rope strength.
It’s likely anyone who has ever used ropes has learned to tie knots – to create eyes, connect rope to objects or even just for decoration. There’s a knot for every application and for many applications there is no better solution than a knot. Nonetheless it is important to be aware of the limitations of knots.
Every time a rope is distorted, strength is lost. When a rope is bent around itself or an object, some of the strength quoted by the manufacturer is lost. A bent rope means some of the fibres on the outside of the curve will have to carry more load while fibres on the inside may take none of the load.
In addition, parts of the rope in a knot may be compressed and the fibres unable to move to share load. These factors and more combine to give a complex mechanical system that ultimately reduces a rope’s strength.
The level of strength reduction can be substantial. In some cases, strength can be reduced by over 50 percent. However, this will depend on many factors, including the type of knot, how the knot is tied, how neat it is, how the rope is loaded, the design of the rope and so on.
Any knot in typical polyester or nylon ropes should be expected to retain 50 percent of its original strength. Ropes made from HMPE or LCP type material (for example, Dyneema or Vectran) should be assumed to retain 40 percent of their strength when knotted, while Aramid ropes could retain as little as 30 percent of their strength.
In contrast to these figures, a well spliced rope will typically retain 90 percent of its quoted strength. In fact, some ropes (typically HMPE products) are often quoted with spliced strength, as this is how the product is tested. If strength of termination is critical then a splice is always the preferred choice.
There is much healthy debate about what knots work best for any application and which knot is strongest. Tying knots is a skill… it needs to be practiced! There are numerous examples of accidents and injuries caused when an incorrectly tied knot behaves unexpectedly. It’s better to know a few simple multipurpose knots that can be reliably tied every time than to try and use the ‘best’ exotic knot but make an error in tying it.
The following ‘Magnificent Seven’ knots can be used to solve almost any rope problem. Notice some of the same knots can be used for many different applications. If you only learn one knot, learn a Figure 8 and how to use its many variations.
Knot types and how they can be used:
• Fig 8 – Stopper, Eye, To join ropes, To attach to something, Friction hitch
• Alpine butterfly – Eyes in middle of rope, ‘Y’ hangs, etc.
• Reef knot – Joining 2 ropes
• Sheet bend – Joining 2 ropes of different size
• Clove hitch – Attaching a rope to something
• Round turn and 2 half hitches – Attaching a rope to something
• Prusik Knot – Friction hitch to grip rope
The study of knots can be fascinating and a lifetime’s work. The Ashley Book of Knots, often considered the definitive work on the subject, contains over 3800 knots and 7000 illustrations and took Clifford Ashley a lifetime to compile!