Testing the Theory of Plus One
Published on November 7th, 2018
by Adam Loory, UK Sailmakers
Those of us at UK Sailmakers, as is the case with most sailmaking companies, have been working with sailors and sailing organizations to grow our sport through the development of new forms of racing that are both fun and accessible.
Many people have told me that they don’t race more because getting crew is such a problem. Reflecting that statistic, the number of boats competing in doublehanded distance races has been growing over the last decade.
For several years I have been trying to get a new shorthanded racing series off the ground recognizing that one appeal of shorthanded sailing is that it much easier to pull together a small crew than a large one. Since not every boat is set up to be sailed well with just two people, and because not all sailors want to exert as much energy sailing as doubleheaders, I developed a new handicap crew-size format that straddles doublehanding and fully-crewed racing.
I am calling this new series “Plus One” since the crew limit is one more person than the tens digit of the boat’s hull length. Therefore, any boat from 20-29.9 feet will race with three crew, any boat in the 30s will sail with four, and so on.
To test the theory, The Storm Trysail Club and the Larchmont Yacht Club agreed to run a Plus One race after the last of the fall regattas on Long Island Sound. That first race was sailed October 21 in a howling, cold northerly. While the race was not the best test of the new shorthanded theory, this inaugural Plus One race turned out to be a great test of heavy air seamanship challenging everyone on each crew to perform at the highest level.
With the wind blowing 21-25 knots and gusting into the 30s, Nick Langone, The Storm Trysail Club’s PRO, wasn’t sure if he should start the race. Instead of making the call on whether to race, he polled the fleet over the radio and heard a unanimous “we are here to race.”
Because no one flew spinnakers or changed jibs during the race, it was not the optimal test of shorthanded crews handling sail changes, spinnaker sets, jibes and douses; but the Plus One teams sailed their boats under reduced canvas in conditions that many full crews normally elect to skip.
Twelve boats registered for the regatta, seven made it to the starting line and six started the race. Only four finished on a sunny day where the wind chill was in the 30s and the winds gusted to the 30s.
On my custom 40-footer Soulmates, we raced with a reefed main and No. 4 genoa. Unfortunately, the jib halyard broke just before the gun, which made us late to the start. But the crew came together and we fought our way back to cross the finish line first. Josh Burack sailed his J/105 Peregrina well and crossed the finish line second and finished first on corrected time. Justin Scagnelli sailing the J/88 Albondigas finished third and Alex Helfand’s Hunter 37 Shadowfox finished fourth.
The best comment came from Alex Helfand: “We saw 35 knots of wind, yet nothing broke; I am very happy. I like the (Plus One) crew format. While we didn’t not get to test flying the spinnaker, a solid crew of four makes for a very enjoyable day. There was not one point where I recalled raising my voice; everyone worked well together and had plenty to do.”
Hamish Young, who is a veteran of many doublehanded races, is a Plus One convert. “I have two sons who have sailed with me and whenever I raced doublehanded. In the past, I had to leave one son home. Now I can sail with both my sons and one more, too. I’m looking forward to more races sailed with this crew configuration.”
What I wanted to show with this race were the benefits of Plus One over double-handed racing. First, not all boats are set-up for competitive double-handed racing. Further, if one of the two double-handed sailors goes overboard, a single-handed MOB retrieval is not within every sailor’s skill set.
With Plus One, there are still enough people to manage headsails with luff tapes and spinnakers that are set without a sock. At the same time, because you’re not sailing with the full complement of crew, everyone is more involved with racing the boat-there are no purely “rail meat” crewmembers; everyone has multiple jobs to do so they learn different skills, and the owner has fewer bodies to wrangle before leaving the dock.
As the creator of the Plus One concept, I really wanted to get the first race off, but for the weather for the five days before the race was worrying. I kept telling all those who were worried about getting hit by the big breeze, “Don’t worry, it is way too early to predict winds we will have.” But as Josh Reisberg pointed out, this was the first time in memory when the wind forecast was spot on five days in advance.
Here is a link to a video posted by Hamish Young before his Ben. 36.7 Jamala IV had to drop out.
1. Peregrina, Josh Burack, J/105, 90 rating, Elapsed Time 2:01:50 Corrected time 2:13:15
2. Soulmates, Adam Loory, Custom 40, 21 rating, Elapsed Time 1:50:07 Corrected time 2:15:00
3. Albondigas, Justin Scagnelli, J/88, 81 rating, Elapsed Time 2:06:11 Corrected time: 2:19:59
4. Shadowfox, Alex Helfand, Hunter 37, 102 rating, Elapsed Time: 2:13:59 Corrected time: 2:23:51
DNF: Frequent Flyer, Alistair Duke, Ben First 36.7
DNF: Jamala IV, Hamish Young, Ben First 36.7
DNS: Reviver, J/112e, Scott Devine
DNC: Thin Man, J/92, Todd Aven
DNC: Sirius, J/33, Charles Taus
DNC: Moonshine, Columbia 32, Allen Fligor
DNC: Abilyn, J/120, Josh Reisberg
DNC: Upsetter, J/80, Jason Viseltear