Resume Hand Wringing

Published on November 14th, 2018

WindCheck, a monthly magazine devoted to sailors and boaters in the Northeast, is one of our favorites. In this report, publisher Ben Cesare takes on the topic of youth training:


I recently exalted the WindCheck Community to celebrate the efforts of our kids and their supporters and pointed out some great successes. Well, now that junior sailing is over, and program heads take a well-deserved breath before diving back into evaluating the pros and cons of their efforts, I’m going to jump right down onto the tracks and touch that third rail!

I think the Optimist stinks as an early trainer. Here is why…

Like all sports, we are introducing our kids to sailing at a younger and younger age. It used to be 9 years old, and now programs start as young as 6. What does a typical 9 year old like? They tend to like other kids and want to be in close proximity to them.

They don’t like to be scared. They don’t really have a handle on “seamanship” nor, unless they are gifted, the physics of sailing. And finally, sad to say, they may be a bit more spoiled than prior generations and like quick satisfaction (digital!) so menial chores, like bailing, turn them off more quickly.

Let me relate a recent conversation with my ten year old, right before a very relaxed, local, season-end regatta.

“Daddy, would you rather (we play a lot of “Would you rather”) win a race, and not get to talk to your friends, or finish last, but get to talk to your friends the whole time?” “Ummmmm…….” “Well I’ll tell you, I’d rather finish last and be able to talk to my friends.” And it got better (or worse). I said, “Hold on. When you are in the field playing baseball, you don’t get to talk to your friends!” “OH, yes I do…and besides, baseball is FUN!” Ouch.

The Optimist has evolved from the simple pram into a full-on, fragile, racing dinghy. This is due to the trickle-down effect of parents and coaches applying the same best practices of racing seamanship that are generally viewed as necessary for “success” to what was supposed to be a trainer.

And yes, in the last 40 years, the Optimist has broken all records of popularity worldwide for racing participation by young kids. Sailing centers, yacht clubs, associations, manufacturers and boat shops, many of whom advertise with WindCheck, quite rightly have supported this and provided all kinds of effort to make this happen.

Credit goes to one of the advertisers in WindCheck, McLaughlin Boat Works, which produces the SailCube, a roto-molded polyethylene boat specifically focused on being a simpler, more durable Optimist for training.

But what about the continuation rates of participation in sailing? I know that I personally did not start to really enjoy sailing (beyond the friends part, sponge tag, and general horsing around) until about age 13. That was when I got hold of a Laser. No, it is not that a light bulb went off and all of a sudden I started training like mad, possessed with making Bruce Kirby’s great design go fast. It was because me and my buddies treated it like a jungle gym.

I’m not sure how the mast step held up, but we must have flipped that boat over 20 times a day and performed countless other seamanship indignities on it, just for fun. And as age 14 rolled around, and the beast was somewhat tamed, I still was terrified, at 140 lbs., if it blew over 10 knots (a feature of growing up on Long Island Sound).

But that too fell away, because the satisfaction of going fast, the responsiveness, and the knowledge that the worst that could happen was that I would get wet and have to right the boat, ultimately won the day, and I began to love to race.

I think we need a better tool for the job. The Laser is too big for the ages I am concerned with. The O’pen BIC has promise, and I’ll dig into that next!

When I first started with WindCheck last spring, some of my friends were hoping I would be controversial. Well, here you go. Let me know how you feel about this: ben@windcheckmagazine.com

Tags: , ,



Back to Top ↑

Get Your Sailing News Fix!

Your daily or weekly download by email.

Subscribe - In popup

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We’ll keep your information safe.